Skip to content

Articles·A reader’s question

Is local detail too parochial?

A novel needs a place. That place does not have to be New York, Paris or London. Readers like being taken somewhere they have not stood.

A reader wrote: I’ve put a lot of local detail into my novel. Is it going to be too parochial to interest anyone beyond the parish?

Every novel needs a sense of place, and that place does not always have to be a famous city. Readers like to be taken somewhere they have not necessarily visited. It is a pleasure to get the flavour of a locality — the turns of phrase, the landscape, the architecture, the climate, the thing people argue about in the queue. That is a more tempting prospect than a generic Anytown in which every specific has been sanded off for fear of excluding someone.

So do not be afraid of being parochial. It did Thomas Hardy’s career no harm. The Wessex he invented was local in its ditches and its weathers, and it travelled because the people in it wanted things a stranger could recognise. Specificity is not the enemy of a wide readership. Vagueness is. A reader in another country can enter a real street. They cannot enter a street that was designed to belong to nobody.

The limit is indulgence. If a paragraph exists only to prove you know the name of a lane, cut it. If the lane changes how two people speak to each other, or how long it takes bad news to arrive, keep the lane.